Read our latest magazine

19 November 2026

Phil Turner

Photo Credit: Roe-Parkin Creative

This amateur production of the joyous Christmas comedy is a joy from start to finish, putting the real stars of the show – the kids – right at the heart of the action.

It might still be a little early for panto season, but if you’re looking for something to get you firmly into the Christmas spirit, STOS Theatre Company’s production of Nativity! The Musical at Sheffield Lyceum is just about the perfect place to start.

The Sheffield-based company has been entertaining audiences for over 120 years, and its latest production, based on the much-loved film starring Martin Freeman, is an absolute festive treat.

There’s more than a hint of pantomime about proceedings, largely thanks to the wonderfully entertaining Sam Widowson as Mr Poppy. He’s the show’s unofficial master of ceremonies, breaking the fourth wall, engaging with the audience and injecting an infectious energy into practically every scene. He never quite tips into full-blown panto territory, but the spirit is certainly there.

Alongside him, Richard Granger is excellent as Paul Maddens, the lovelorn, Christmas-hating teacher whose enthusiasm for the festive season has long since evaporated. Granger is the perfect straight man to Widowson’s whirlwind of chaos, and together they form the beating heart of the production. If Granger provides the steady rhythm that keeps everything ticking along, Widowson is the racing pulse that sends the whole thing into overdrive. The pair of them are wonderful throughout.

Credit: Roe-Parkin Creative

The supporting adult cast are also impressive. Charlotte Waxman delivers some lovely vocal performances as Jennifer Lore, while Matt Bevan makes for a suitably villainous Gordon Shakespeare, relishing every opportunity to turn up the nastiness. A special mention, too, for Lily Coates, whose brief appearance as a Hollywood studio receptionist is an absolute scene-stealer. It’s a small role, but she makes every second count.

But as good as the grown-ups are, the real stars of Nativity! are undoubtedly the children.

The production features two rotating casts of youngsters, and I caught the Wednesday evening performance. The children representing St Bernadette’s and their considerably more polished rivals at Oakmoor are an absolute joy to watch. Naturally, the St Bernadette’s contingent have more opportunities to shine, with individual solos, plenty of comedy and the all-important final performance, but what really stands out is the sheer personality bursting from the stage.

There’s something genuinely heartwarming about watching these young performers throw themselves into the production with such enthusiasm. They’re funny, confident and, above all, supremely talented.

The entire production builds towards the children’s big Christmas performance at the cathedral, and when it finally arrives, we’re treated to a glorious 20-minute celebration of the shows best songs, staging and these are the moments that the audience will take away with them and stay with them long after the curtain has closed.

By the time the final notes rang out, we were all on our feet for a thoroughly deserved standing ovation, grinning from ear to ear and basking in the sort of warm, fuzzy feeling that only Christmas entertainment at its best can deliver.

It might only be November, but thanks to STOS and a ridiculously talented bunch of youngsters, Christmas has officially arrived in Sheffield.