Disclaimer: This article is not intended to be a recommendation. The author is not responsible for any resulting actions of the company during your trading experience. The information provided in this article may not be accurate or up-to-date. Any trading or financial decision you make is your sole responsibility, and you must not rely on any information provided here. We do not provide any warranties regarding the information on this website and are not responsible for any losses or damages incurred as a result of trading or investing.
Keeping a smartphone for longer can make good financial sense, particularly if it still does everything you need it to. But as your device gets older, deciding whether to pay for extra protection isn’t as easy a decision. While its market value may have fallen, an unexpected repair could still leave you with a sizeable bill.
How smartphone value changes over time
Your phone generally loses value as manufacturers release newer models and second-hand prices fall. Factors like condition also matter. A well-kept three-year-old handset with a healthy battery should remain useful and relatively valuable, while one with a cracked case or unreliable charging port may be worth considerably less.
Check current prices for the same model, storage capacity and approximate condition on reputable second-hand marketplaces. This gives you a realistic replacement value rather than relying on what you originally paid.
Understanding the cost of repairs
Age doesn’t necessarily make a smartphone cheap to fix. A replacement screen might still be costly because the repair requires specific parts and skilled labour. Battery replacements tend to cost less, but several problems at once can quickly change the calculation.
Ask a reputable repairer for a quote and compare it with the cost of buying an equivalent refurbished or second-hand device. If a £180 repair would restore a phone that you could replace for £220, spending heavily on protection or repairs may offer limited financial benefit.
Reviewing available protection options
You can protect an older device in several ways, from using a sturdy case and screen protector to setting money aside for emergencies. You could also consider taking out phone insurance to cover events like accidental damage, theft or loss, although cover varies between policies.
Read the terms before deciding. Check the premium, excess, exclusions and maximum claim value, then calculate what you could actually receive after paying any excess. You should also confirm whether your handset’s age makes it eligible for cover.
Balancing cost against risk
Think about how you use your device rather than judging the risk from its age alone. If your phone usually stays at home or in an office, you might face less exposure than someone who commutes daily or regularly uses their handset outdoors.
Your ability to absorb an unexpected expense matters too. Paying £10 each month may seem unnecessary if you could comfortably replace a £150 phone, whereas predictable monthly costs might suit you better if an unplanned replacement would strain your budget.
Choosing what suits your circumstances
There’s no single answer that works for every older smartphone and owner. Consider what your handset would cost to replace today and how expensive repairs could be, and also how much disruption losing it would cause.
Base your choice on the phone you own and the way you use it. A device that holds little resale value could still matter greatly if you rely on it for work, banking, travel or staying in touch, so practical importance can sometimes matter as much as its price.
